Hidden Concerns of ETFs Investments: What Every Investor Need to Know

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have emerged as a favored instrument among investors, offering diversification and the flexibility of stock-like trading. Their growing popularity is undeniable, with assets under management soaring globally.

However, as with any investment vehicle, ETFs are not without their intricacies and potential pitfalls. It is imperative for discerning investors to look beyond the surface appeal and understand the underlying concerns associated with ETFs.

This article aims to shed light on some of the often-overlooked challenges and considerations pertaining to ETF investments, providing a comprehensive perspective for those seeking to make informed decisions in the dynamic world of finance.


What are ETFs?

An ETF, or Exchange Traded Fund, is a type of investment fund and exchange-traded product with tradable shares on a stock exchange. Here’s a more detailed overview of what an ETF is:

  1. Diversification: An ETF typically holds a collection of assets, such as stocks or commodities. This means that when you buy an ETF, you’re effectively investing in a diverse range of assets at once, offering a level of diversification similar to mutual funds.
  2. Trade Like Stocks: Unlike mutual funds, which have their net asset value (NAV) calculated at the end of each trading day, ETFs are listed on stock exchanges and can be bought and sold throughout the trading day at market prices, just like individual stocks.
  3. Cost-Efficient: ETFs often have lower expense ratios than traditional mutual funds, mainly because many ETFs are passively managed, aiming to track a specific index rather than actively trying to outperform it.
  4. Transparency: ETFs typically disclose their holdings on a daily basis, which means investors can see exactly which assets the ETF holds.
  5. Dividends: ETFs can earn dividend income from the underlying assets they hold. This income is then either reinvested or distributed to shareholders.
  6. Flexibility: Investors can implement various investment strategies with ETFs, such as short selling or buying on margin, as they would with stocks.
  7. Variety: There are many types of ETFs available, ranging from those that track broad market indices to those focused on specific sectors, commodities, or investment themes.

Related: Islamic ETF: The Things You Should Know

6 Critical ETF Concerns Every Investor Must Be Aware

Before incorporating ETFs into an investment strategy, it is crucial to delve deep into their critical concerns. Below, we explore six such vital concerns every investor must be acquainted with.

1- Liquidity Mismatches

At a surface level, ETFs often boast high liquidity, making them attractive to many investors. However, liquidity mismatches can arise when there’s a disparity between the tradability of the ETF itself and its underlying assets.

For instance, an ETF might hold illiquid stocks from emerging markets. While the ETF shares can be traded swiftly, selling the underlying assets in stressed market conditions might not be as straightforward.

This mismatch can lead to the ETF’s price deviating from its net asset value (NAV), causing potential losses for uninformed investors.

2- Tracking Errors

Most ETFs’ primary objective is to mirror a specific index’s performance, whether it’s related to stocks or other assets. Tracking errors occur when there’s a difference between the ETF’s performance and that of its benchmark index.

Factors such as management fees, the replication method used (full replication versus sampling), and dividend reinvestment can cause these discrepancies.

A significant tracking error might mean the ETF is not effectively achieving its primary goal, and investors aren’t getting the performance they anticipate.

3- Counterparty Risk

Especially relevant to synthetic ETFs, counterparty risk arises when the ETF relies on derivatives and swaps with other institutions to achieve its desired performance. In simple terms, if the ‘counterparty’ (usually a bank or another financial entity) defaults or fails to honor its obligations, the ETF might suffer.

Synthetic ETFs, in particular, don’t directly own the assets of the index they track but instead rely on these counterparties’ promises, increasing the associated risks.

4- Tax Implications

The tax efficiency of ETFs is a major selling point for many investors. However, tax implications can vary based on the ETF structure and the investor’s jurisdiction.

For instance, in some regions, dividend distributions might be taxed differently than capital gains.

Additionally, certain complex ETFs, like those dealing with commodities or currencies, might have unique tax considerations.

It’s imperative for investors to consult with tax professionals to understand the implications fully.

5- Complexity and Opaque Structures

The world of ETFs is vast, encompassing straightforward funds that track major indices to more intricate products like leveraged or inverse ETFs. The latter can amplify gains but also exacerbate losses.

Additionally, the strategies these complex ETFs employ might not be transparent, making it challenging for average investors to comprehend fully the associated risks.

Without a thorough understanding, investing in these ETFs might lead to unforeseen adverse outcomes.

6- Fee Structures

While ETFs often promote their low expense ratios, especially when compared to traditional mutual funds, additional costs might lurk beneath the surface.

Beyond the stated management fee, investors might encounter costs related to bid-ask spreads, especially if they’re trading in and out of less liquid ETFs.

Over time, these hidden fees can erode returns, making it crucial for investors to assess the total cost of ownership comprehensively.

Read Also: Are ETFs Halal: A Complete Guide for Muslim Investors

How to Minimize Risks in ETFs: A Handy Listicle

As with any financial instrument, the glimmer of ETFs comes with its set of risks. But fear not, for many of these risks can be mitigated with prudent strategies and a keen eye. Read our handy listicle to discover ways to minimize potential pitfalls and optimize your ETF investments.

  1. Diversify: One of the foundational principles of investing is diversification. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Spread your investments across various ETFs covering different sectors, asset classes, and geographical regions.
  2. Understand What You’re Buying: Before investing, thoroughly research each ETF. Understand the underlying assets, the index it’s tracking, and its overall investment strategy.
  3. Avoid Illiquid ETFs: Check the average trading volume of the ETF. Illiquid ETFs can have wider bid-ask spreads, leading to higher trading costs. Additionally, in times of market stress, liquidity concerns can exacerbate price discrepancies.
  4. Beware of Complex Strategies: Some ETFs, like leveraged or inverse ETFs, employ intricate strategies that can magnify losses. Unless you fully understand and are comfortable with these complexities, it’s wise to steer clear.
  5. Monitor Tracking Errors: Regularly compare the performance of the ETF with its benchmark index. A significant and persistent tracking error might be a red flag, indicating potential management or replication issues.
  6. Seek Expert Advice: If in doubt, consult a financial advisor. They can provide guidance tailored to your financial situation, helping you navigate the vast world of ETFs more confidently.

Hidden Concerns of ETF Investments FAQs

How do premiums and discounts occur in ETF pricing?

Premiums and discounts arise when the market price of the ETF deviates from its net asset value (NAV). Factors like supply and demand imbalances, trading interruptions, or discrepancies in foreign market operating times can contribute to these price differences.

What are non-traditional ETFs, and why should I be cautious?

Non-traditional ETFs include leveraged, inverse, and leveraged-inverse ETFs. They use financial derivatives and can return a multiple or inverse of their benchmarks, which introduces more significant volatility and risk, especially for long-term holdings.

Can the creation and redemption process impact ETF prices?

Yes, the creation and redemption process helps maintain an ETF’s market price close to its NAV. If there are disruptions or imbalances in this process, it can lead to premiums or discounts in the ETF’s price.

What risks are associated with ETFs holding international assets?

Besides currency risk, international ETFs can be exposed to geopolitical risks, differences in regulations, and varying levels of market development and transparency. These can introduce added volatility compared to domestic ETFs.

How do dividend payments work with ETFs, and are there any associated risks?

ETFs typically pass on dividends received from underlying holdings to investors. However, there might be delays in payments, tax withholdings for international assets, or unexpected changes in dividend distributions, impacting anticipated returns.

Are there any concerns related to ETFs closing or delisting?

Yes, if an ETF provider decides to close an ETF, typically due to insufficient assets or low trading volume, investors might be forced to sell at an inopportune time, face potential tax consequences, or experience a delay in receiving their invested capital.

Do thematic or niche ETFs have unique risks?

Thematic ETFs focus on specific market niches or trends (e.g., technology, green energy). While they offer targeted exposure, they can also have higher concentration risks, making them potentially more volatile than broader market ETFs.

Can the underlying index of an ETF change, and what are the implications?

Yes, sometimes the benchmark index of an ETF might change due to various reasons, like mergers or shifts in market focus. Such changes can alter the risk and return profile of the ETF, requiring investors to re-evaluate their positions.

Bottom Line

ETFs undeniably present a compelling avenue for investors, blending the diversification benefits of mutual funds with the trading conveniences of stocks. Their appeal spans from beginners venturing into the financial markets for the first time to seasoned investors expanding their portfolios. However, the allure of ETFs should be met with a discerning gaze.

Challenges that might elude the untrained eye are hidden beneath the surface of their convenience.

So, as you tread the intricate pathways of the financial world, let this exploration serve as a reminder: in investments, as in life, a deeper understanding often leads to more profound, more rewarding experiences. It’s always worth peeling back the layers to discover what lies beneath.


To read more about Islamic finance-related topics, please click here and visit our academy.

Feel free to sign up for our free stock screening services at musaffa.com.

Disclaimer: Important information