Islamic finance is a system of banking and financial activities that operates in accordance with the principles of Shariah (Islamic law). It differs from conventional finance in several ways, primarily in its prohibition of riba (interest) and emphasis on ethical, equitable transactions. One of the most common financial instruments used in Islamic finance is Murabaha. This article will explain what Murabaha is, how it works, and why it is an essential part of the Islamic financial system.
Introduction to Islamic Finance
Islamic finance is deeply rooted in the ethical and legal traditions of Islam. At its core, it seeks to promote justice, fairness, and social responsibility in financial dealings. The two key prohibitions in Islamic finance are riba (interest) and gharar (excessive uncertainty or speculation). Islamic financial institutions must adhere to these principles and engage in trade, investment, and other activities in ways that do not exploit individuals or encourage unethical behavior.
One of the fundamental reasons Islamic finance prohibits interest-based transactions is that they are viewed as exploitative, with one party earning money without taking on any real risk or offering value. Instead, Islamic finance emphasizes the sharing of risks and rewards through trade-based transactions or investment partnerships.
Murabaha is one such trade-based contract that has become central to modern Islamic finance. It is commonly used to provide financing for the purchase of goods, particularly in real estate and trade finance.
Read more: Key Benefits of Choosing Finance Governed by Islamic Principles.
What is Murabaha?
Murabaha is a type of cost-plus financing that is compliant with Islamic principles. In a Murabaha contract, the seller (usually an Islamic bank or financial institution) sells a product or asset to a buyer (the customer) at a pre-agreed price that includes the cost of the item plus a fixed profit margin. The key difference between a Murabaha transaction and a conventional loan is that the bank does not simply lend money to the buyer to purchase the item. Instead, the bank purchases the item itself and then sells it to the buyer.
For example, if a customer wants to buy a car using Murabaha, the Islamic bank would first purchase the car from the dealer and then sell it to the customer at a higher price, reflecting the cost of the car plus a pre-agreed profit margin. The customer then pays this total amount back to the bank over an agreed period.
How Murabaha Differs from Conventional Loans
In a conventional loan, a financial institution lends money to the borrower with the expectation of earning interest over time. In contrast, in Murabaha, no money is directly lent to the customer. Instead, the bank buys and resells a tangible asset, and the profit earned is not considered interest (riba) but rather a fair markup for the service provided.
The key feature of Murabaha is its transparency. The buyer knows exactly how much the item costs and what markup is being applied. This ensures clarity in the transaction, which aligns with Islamic principles that discourage exploitation and ambiguity.
Also read: Halal Investing vs. Conventional Investing: What’s the Difference?
How Murabaha Works
Step-by-Step Explanation of the Murabaha Process
The Murabaha contract follows a clear step-by-step process, which includes the following stages:
- Asset Identification:
- The client identifies the asset or product they wish to purchase, such as a car, real estate, or equipment. The Islamic bank is then approached to facilitate the purchase using a Murabaha contract.
- Bank Purchase of Asset:
- The Islamic bank agrees to purchase the asset on behalf of the client. The bank negotiates with the seller (e.g., a car dealer) to purchase the item at market price. During this stage, the bank takes ownership of the asset and bears the risks associated with it.
- Resale to the Client:
- After purchasing the asset, the bank resells it to the client at a price that includes both the original cost and an agreed-upon profit margin. The profit margin is pre-determined and mutually agreed upon before the contract is signed.
- Payment Terms:
- The client agrees to repay the bank the total price, including the markup, either in installments or as a lump sum, depending on the terms of the agreement. The markup remains fixed, and there are no additional interest charges or penalties unless explicitly agreed upon (as long as they do not contradict Islamic law).
Key Principles and Conditions of a Murabaha Contract
For a Murabaha contract to be valid under Islamic law, it must meet the following conditions:
- Full Disclosure: The seller (the bank) must disclose the cost of the product and the amount of profit they are adding. There can be no hidden fees or charges, ensuring transparency.
- Ownership Transfer: The bank must take actual or constructive possession of the asset before reselling it to the client. This means that the bank bears some level of risk, which differentiates it from a conventional loan where there is no such risk.
- No Riba: The profit margin the bank charges is not interest because it is about the sale of a tangible asset rather than money. This ensures compliance with the Islamic prohibition on riba.
Example of a Murabaha Transaction
Imagine a customer wants to buy a house worth $100,000 but doesn’t have the funds to purchase outright. The customer approaches an Islamic bank, and they agree to a Murabaha contract. The bank purchases the house for $100,000 and resells it to the customer for $120,000 (the original cost plus a $20,000 profit margin). The customer agrees to repay this amount over 10 years in equal monthly installments.
In this case, the bank earns its profit by selling the house at a markup, not by charging interest on a loan. This ensures that the transaction is in line with Islamic finance principles.
Also Read: What is Musharakah? Definition, Example, and 2 Types of Musharakah.
Types of Murabaha
Asset-Based Murabaha
This is the most common form of Murabaha, where the transaction involves the sale and purchase of a tangible asset such as real estate, vehicles, or machinery. The buyer and seller know the actual cost of the asset, and the profit margin is pre-agreed.
Commodity Murabaha
Commodity Murabaha or Organized Tawarruq is a Sharia-compliant financing transaction structured around the principles of purchase and sale. In this arrangement, the bank purchases a commodity from a broker. Then it sells it to the customer under a Murabaha agreement, which includes a pre-agreed markup—either as a lump sum or a percentage. After signing the agreement, the customer, who seeks financing, sells the commodity to a third-party broker, with the bank acting as the customer’s agent in the transaction.
Gold and silver cannot be used as the underlying commodities in a Commodity Murabaha sale because they are considered forms of currency under Islamic law.
Controversiality of Commodity Murabaha (Organized Tawarruq)
Commodity Murabaha, also known as Organized Tawarruq, has been the subject of considerable debate among Islamic scholars due to concerns over its structure and practical application. Institutions like the International Council of Fiqh Academy (ICFA) state that more complex forms, such as Reverse Commodity Tawarruq or Organized Tawarruq, do not comply with Shariah. The issue with Organized Tawarruq lies in the financial institution’s role in managing the entire transaction. The institution purchases a commodity from a supplier, sells it to the customer on a deferred basis with a markup, and then acts as the customer’s agent to sell the commodity to a third party in order to provide the customer with cash.
According to AAOIFI (Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions) standard No. 30, article 4/7: “The client shall not delegate the institution or its agent to sell, on his behalf, a commodity that he purchased from the same institution and, similarly, the institution shall not accept such delegation If, however, the regulations do not permit the client to sell the commodity except through the same Institution, he may delegate the Institution to do so after he, actually or constructively, receives the commodity.
However, some scholars permit the use of Organized Tawarruq. In Malaysia for example, the member of the Shariah Advisory Council of the Central Bank of Malaysia has made a resolution that permits the use of organized Tawarruq such as those that include wakalah (agency) and pre-arrangement to be applied in many types of transactions (Bank Negara Malaysia, 2010).
For a more in-depth exploration of Commodity Murabaha and Organized Tawarruq, please refer to the following:
Tawarruq as a Product for Financing within the Islamic Banking System.
What is Tawarruq and How Does It Work in Islamic Finance?
Difference Between Asset-Based and Commodity Murabaha
While both types follow the same structure, asset-based Murabaha deals with tangible products, whereas commodity Murabaha deals with the buying and selling of commodities, often as a way of securing financing. Asset-based Murabaha is primarily for consumer finance, while commodity Murabaha is more common for corporate and institutional needs.
Advantages of Murabaha
Murabaha offers several advantages, particularly for those seeking financial products that adhere to Islamic principles. Some of the key benefits include:
- Transparency: Both parties (the buyer and the bank) are aware of the cost and the profit margin upfront, which ensures clarity in the transaction and prevents exploitation.
- Predictability: Since the markup is agreed upon in advance, the customer knows exactly how much they will need to repay. This makes budgeting easier and reduces the risk of unexpected costs.
- Shariah Compliance: Murabaha contracts align with Islamic law by avoiding riba, ensuring that transactions are ethical and equitable.
Also Read: Takaful vs Conventional Insurance: A Complete Guide.
Challenges and Criticisms of Murabaha
Comparison with Interest-Based Loans
Some critics argue that Murabaha is similar to conventional interest-based loans because the buyer ends up paying more than the market price over time. However, proponents of Islamic finance argue that the key difference lies in the ownership transfer and risk-sharing aspects. Unlike interest-based loans, the bank in a Murabaha transaction takes possession of the asset and bears the risk of ownership until the bank resells the asset.
Potential for Misuse
In certain cases, Murabaha can be misused, particularly in commodity Murabaha transactions, where some argue that the transaction resembles backdoor lending. Islamic scholars and financial institutions are continually working to address these concerns to ensure that Murabaha remains a genuinely ethical alternative to conventional loans.
Ethical Considerations
One of the primary concerns in Islamic finance is ensuring that transactions remain ethical and fair. Murabaha seeks to address this by promoting transparency and fairness, but as with any financial product, misuse is possible. Stringent oversight by Shariah boards within financial institutions helps to maintain the integrity of the system.
Summary
Murabaha is one of the most widely used financial instruments in Islamic finance, offering a Shariah-compliant alternative to conventional loans. By emphasizing transparency, fairness, and the sharing of risk, Murabaha aligns with Islamic principles and provides an ethical way for individuals and businesses to access financing. As Islamic finance continues to grow globally, Murabaha remains a cornerstone of this alternative financial system.
Disclaimer: The content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. It is important to conduct your own research or consult with a financial or investment advisor. All logos or brands are referenced for identification purposes only and do not constitute an endorsement of any kind. This information is accurate as of the date of publication and may not reflect recent changes. Access our comprehensive legal disclaimers at musaffa.com/disclaimer.
Explore the Musaffa App to access the Sharia compliance status of stocks, in-depth reports, top investor portfolios, and more. Elevate your Halal investing experience with our stock forecasts and purification calculator.
