What Investors Look for in Startups Before Investing

Musaffa

May 11, 2026

Introduction

So many founders spend a ton of time crafting the perfect pitch deck before even sending it to investors. I firmly believe one of the most valuable things a founder can do before showing off their baby to potential investors is to ask what investors are looking for. Venture capitalists are often forced to make split second decisions in the matter of minutes to decide whether to schedule a meeting based off of a one page overview of your company. Founders who get term sheets, meetings, and eventually successful exits don’t just have great looking slides- they understand what investors are looking for and build their pitch around the key criteria that matter.

Investing involves many variables, and this approach focuses on seven important factors to consider.

7 Key Things Investors Look for in Startups Before Investing

1. Strong Founding Team

In the very early days, investors were betting more on the people than the product. Initially, they look for a founding team with relevant domain expertise; a mix of skills that are necessary to build a successful company (in particular, the ability to scale); and proof of concept on how that team will execute under tremendous pressure. A technical co-founder can make or break a deep-tech startup; industry experience is just as critical in highly regulated industries as in fast-growing, consumer-facing startups; and the ability to recruit a strong team, sell to customers or clients, and adjust to unexpected road-bumps is key in building successful companies across industries.

The issue is that the solo founder has no background relevant to the service. The team has clear weaknesses that they have not addressed. The founders cannot seem to articulate why they would be the right people to solve this problem. People invest in people, and you need to give them confidence that even as your initial idea evolves into something else, you will have the capacity to execute on the new vision.

2. Large Market Opportunity

For venture investors to get a return on investment, they typically require startups to serve very large markets. While a $50 million industry may support a great, and sufficient, company–a nice business–it is unlikely to be big enough for a venture-scale return on investment. Rather, founders must make the case that the total market is large, and that they can take a significant share.

Describing the market size in a real, human way matters more than throwing around (often wrong) “multi-billion dollar industry” figures. A bottom-up assessment of the potential customer base, the average contract value, and the realistic conversion rates between different stages of the customer journey is much more convincing than an analyst report estimate. Show your customer that you have a deep, insider’s knowledge of the market as opposed to simply regurgitating and overhyping information that is easily accessible.

3. Product-Market Fit

Of the many criteria used to evaluate startups by investors, achieving product-market fit is among the most important but difficult to fake. It means that other than the team, nobody else could have founded the startup, and that real people want what you’ve created badly enough to use it regularly, pay for it (potentially repeatedly) and recommend it to others. Strong customer retention rates, organic growth, customers for whom there would be tragedy where the product no longer exists, are some of the clearest signals for it.

At pre-seed, you can get away with not having product market fit yet, as long as you seem to be asking the right questions and getting good signals early on. At seed and beyond, that lack of signal for product market fit is much harder to explain and as damaging to your ability to raise capital.

4. Traction and Growth Metrics

Traction is proof that real market demand exists for what you’re building. Most investors want to see traction before they’ll even consider talking to you, because it serves as a way to separate reality from fantastic stories you’ve built up in your head. Depending on the stage and business model, this form of proof can take many different forms such as monthly recurring revenue, headcount of active users, week-over-week growth rate, customer retention, and signed letters of intent from early customers.

Growth rate is as important as the actual amount of growth. $10,000 MRR growing at 20% per month to $24,000 in six months to give the investor a clear idea of future potential is a more attractive investment than flat $50,000 per month for six months. Investors are betting on the direction of your company, not the current numbers.

5. Revenue Model

Investors also want to understand how you make money, and whether that will be sustainable and scalable. They want to understand the unit economics: what you charge for your product or service, who is paying for it, how often they pay for it, and what that translates to in terms of revenue. A SaaS business with high gross margins and strong, predictable recurring revenue sounds very different to a marketplace business with very thin take rates and daily transaction volume as a key driver to your revenue.

For companies with multiple revenue streams, these need to be ranked in terms of current contribution and contribution to future growth. This is distinct from being confusingly complex. The best slides on the most common revenue models present the underlying economics in a couple of lines at most, supported by a few key data points to illustrate that the underlying assumptions have real-world basis.

6. Financial Projections

Financial projections are one of the harder factors for investors to evaluate when sizing up startups. While it’s impossible to predict the future, what the investor is really reading is a structured argument for how your company could be worth more in the future based on a set of assumptions and back-of-the-envelope calculations. They are looking to understand the amount of intellectual honesty that went into the making of those projections, i.e. are the assumptions based on strong evidence? Is the capital ask size appropriate for the progress and growth you project in the financials? Do you demonstrate a good understanding of the levers that drive your company’s value?

Unrealistic projections of growth lack credibility. On the other hand, overly conservative projections - which signal little ambition - raises different questions. The goal is for a business plan to reflect realistic ambition for your business and for the model to allow for interrogation by the investor and to reveal consistent thinking about the future of your business.

7. Pitch Deck Quality

Investors usually want to see a pitch deck before they agree to a meeting with the founders. A good pitch deck demonstrates to investors that the founders have a handle on their company and can effectively convey that information as well as understand what is important to investors. A bad pitch deck, on the other hand, can suggest to investors that the founders don’t have a handle on the company, even if they do.

We broke down everything you need to know about creating a strong pitch deck in a blog post on the best practice for the structure of a pitch deck and the most common mistakes you should avoid when presenting a startup.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What do investors check first?

Investors are often influenced by the founding team in a manner that exceeds their consideration of the product, market and numbers. Given the enormous risks and unknowns inherent to any start-up, investors are principally seeking evidence that the individuals behind the venture possess relevant experience and the ability to execute on the idea in order to bring it to fruition. In general, a strong team with a mediocre idea will travel much further than a weak team with a brilliant one.

2. Is traction necessary before approaching investors?

As you raise funding, your traction expectations increase with each stage of capital. At pre-seed, investors hope to see zero traction, but some early evidence that supports your initial hypothesis. For example, a waiting list of customers paying for the product/service, early user metrics, qualitative evidence of user behavior, or just general “love” for the product from early users. Seed and beyond expects moats of recurring revenue, engaged users, or sticky retention. Go look for all of these metrics before your seed investors even know you exist, and you’ll likely get a “no”.

3. How important is valuation to investors?

Valuation is key to the economics of the deal for both the investor and founder. Investors will look at the valuation at your company relative to comparable companies, growth rates and prospects for future growth. Setting the valuation too high for where your company is at and the justification you have for it can be very damaging and take a lot out of your negotiating capital in future rounds. This is one of the key areas where you are demonstrating your understanding of the market that you are competing in.

4. Do investors review financial models in detail?

DC does anyone actually look at the financial model, besides to puke all over assumptions in due diligence? Yes, investors do look at your financial model. They especially look at the financial model during due diligence because they will use your financial model to understand the unit economics of your company (CAC, LTV, GM etc.) and then stress test your company’s assumptions and drivers as they build out their own projections of your company’s future growth. You want your financial model to withstand the scrutiny put on it and be driven by clear, sensible assumptions and drivers to minimize harm and give you a chance to recover from tough questions before they devolve into hysterical inquiring that you can’t recover from.

5. How can startups become investor ready?

Typically, a startup first needs to become investor-ready before approaching any potential investors. This means that the startup must show that it is strong in all of the key startup evaluation criteria (e.g. strong team, demonstration of progress (trailing tails), large and credible market opportunity, etc.) and have all of the appropriate documentation available to potential investors (e.g. a formal pitch deck, financial model, data room, etc.). The startup should also use experienced startup advisors early on to hit this milestone as quickly as possible.

Disclaimer: Musaffa Academy articles are provided for informational purposes only, and are not research reports or legal, tax, investment, or financial advice. Content may include historical or hypothetical data; past performance does not guarantee future results.

Stock screenings, halal status, grades, and classifications are based on AAOIFI methodology and the oversight of Musaffa’s Shariah scholars. The content is not tailored to your financial situation, risk tolerance, or investment objectives. Always conduct your own research or consult a qualified financial advisor before making decisions.

Musaffa Islamic Social Responsible Investing (MISRI) proprietary rankings are internally developed by Musaffa and are currently in beta. While we continuously work to improve accuracy and reliability, no guarantees are made regarding completeness or correctness.

Logos and brand names are used for identification only and do not imply endorsement. Information is accurate as of the publication date and may change. All content, materials, and methodologies are the exclusive property of Musaffa and are protected by copyright law.

For full details, please visit: https://musaffa.com/disclaimer